Contradicto Play Contradicto

Debate motion Tech

AI will create more jobs than it destroys

This motion is a prediction about the future of work: will artificial intelligence, on balance, add more jobs than it removes? It is tricky because nobody can see the future, so the debate turns on how well history guides us, how fast the change happens, and whether new jobs reach the same people who lost the old ones.

FOR Argue that the motion is right.

AGAINST Argue that the motion is wrong.

Arguments FOR

Arguments AGAINST

Sample openers

FOR

People said the same about tractors, telephones, and computers, and today more people work than ever. History is on my side.

AGAINST

History says machines replace hands, but this time the machine is coming for the thinking, and that changes everything.

How a match plays

Questions

What is the strongest rebuttal to the history argument?

Ask whether the past is really comparable. Earlier machines did narrow physical tasks, leaving humans to move into thinking work. If AI can do thinking work too, where do people move next? Make your opponent name the new jobs and explain why AI cannot do them.

Should I use job statistics or forecasts?

Be careful. Jurors punish numbers without a clear source, and forecasts about AI vary wildly. You will do better with reasoning and familiar examples, like a bank teller, a translator, or a delivery driver, than with figures your opponent can simply deny.

Who is this motion good for?

It suits classes in economics, technology, or careers, and it makes a strong practice motion for serious debaters. It is less of a party pick, because it rewards careful reasoning more than jokes, though a good analogy always helps.

More motions

All motions