Contradicto Play Contradicto

Debate motion Daily Debate

Cash should never be phased out

As cards and phone payments spread, some shops no longer take coins and notes. This motion says cash must stay, forever. It is a strong debate because it touches privacy, inclusion, convenience, and crime all at once. Note the word never: the FOR side must defend a permanent rule, while the AGAINST side only needs to show a future without cash could be better.

FOR Argue that the motion is right.

AGAINST Argue that the motion is wrong.

Arguments FOR

Arguments AGAINST

Sample openers

FOR

The day the payment network goes down, the only person still buying bread will be the one with coins in their pocket.

AGAINST

Defending cash forever is like promising to keep phone boxes on every corner just in case. Times change, and so should money.

How a match plays

Questions

What is the strongest rebuttal to the inclusion argument?

Argue that the answer is to include people in digital payments, through free basic accounts and simple prepaid cards, rather than keeping an expensive cash system forever. Then press the word never: your opponent must defend cash even if no one needs it.

How do I win the jury on this one?

Use vivid, real situations: a power cut at the supermarket, an elderly neighbour without a smartphone, a shop robbery. Jurors reward clear impact. Do not quote crime or fraud figures unless you can name a source, because made-up numbers hurt you.

Is this motion too political for a class?

Not really. It touches policy, but it rarely splits people along party lines. It suits economics, citizenship, or technology lessons, and works on streams too, because everyone has a story about card machines failing at the worst moment.

More motions

All motions