Contradicto Play Contradicto

Debate motion Hot takes

Cereal is a soup

Cereal floats in a liquid, is eaten from a bowl with a spoon, and sometimes goes soggy. So is it a soup? This motion is a classic food definition argument. It is fun because it sounds absurd, and hard because you must build a real definition of soup and defend it against strange edge cases your opponent will throw at you.

FOR Argue that the motion is right.

AGAINST Argue that the motion is wrong.

Arguments FOR

Arguments AGAINST

Sample openers

FOR

Bowl, spoon, solid bits floating in liquid. If it looks like soup and slurps like soup, it is soup.

AGAINST

Nobody has ever said, I am feeling ill, could you bring me a hot bowl of cornflakes?

How a match plays

Questions

How do I win a definition debate like this?

Set a clear definition in your first turn and make your opponent fight on your ground. Then test their definition with funny edge cases, like a milkshake or a salad. Jurors reward clear thinking, quick rebuttals, and humour that actually proves a point.

What is the best rebuttal to the bowl and spoon argument?

Point out that ice cream, yogurt, and fruit salad are also eaten from bowls with spoons, and nobody calls them soup. The container and the cutlery cannot define a dish. Ask what makes soup soup beyond the bowl.

Who is this motion for?

It is great for parties, streams, and classroom warm-ups. On Contradicto, silly definition motions like this are a low-pressure way to practise clear arguments, because there is nothing at stake except your dignity at breakfast.

More motions

All motions