Contradicto Play Contradicto

Debate motion Absurd

Dragons would make terrible pets

Fire-breathing, flying, and famously fond of gold: would dragons really be awful to keep at home? This motion is pure fantasy, but arguing it well means treating it like a real question about animal care, safety, and what makes a good pet. The fun is building vivid, logical cases about a creature nobody has ever owned.

FOR Argue that the motion is right.

AGAINST Argue that the motion is wrong.

Arguments FOR

Arguments AGAINST

Sample openers

FOR

Any pet whose sneeze can set your sofa on fire is not a pet; it is a very expensive emergency.

AGAINST

A loyal friend, a home security system, and a ride to school, all in one. Show me a hamster that does that.

How a match plays

Questions

How do I make a fantasy argument convincing?

Agree on what dragons are like, using common ideas from stories, then reason carefully from there. Jurors reward logic and humour together. Ask practical questions: where does it sleep, what does it eat, how is it trained? Concrete details make fantasy feel real.

What is the best rebuttal to the danger argument?

Point out that many pets were once wild and dangerous, like wolves. With training, care, and responsible owners, dangerous animals can become companions. Fire risk can be managed, just as people manage risks with large dogs or horses.

Is this suitable for younger players or a party?

Yes, it is ideal for younger players, families, and parties. It needs no research, invites creativity, and is a gentle way to learn how to build and test arguments. It is also great fun on a stream.

More motions

All motions