Contradicto Play Contradicto

Debate motion Daily Debate

Elevators should have music

Elevator music is a famous joke, but is it a good idea? This motion asks whether lifts should play music for passengers. It is lighthearted and very relatable, since everyone knows the awkward silence of a crowded lift. The debate turns on whether music makes short rides more pleasant and calm, or is just noise forced on people.

FOR Argue that the motion is right.

AGAINST Argue that the motion is wrong.

Arguments FOR

Arguments AGAINST

Sample openers

FOR

Ten strangers, one tiny box, total silence. Music is the kindest thing a lift can offer.

AGAINST

Lifts take you up and down. They do not need to choose my soundtrack while they do it.

How a match plays

Questions

How do I argue such a small, everyday motion well?

Make it bigger by focusing on comfort, choice, and shared spaces. Use relatable moments, like silent crowded rides or annoying repeated tunes. Jurors reward humour and clear rebuttals, so answer your opponent's best example directly.

What is the strongest rebuttal to the awkward silence argument?

Say that awkwardness lasts only seconds, and many people like quiet. Then point out that music is not the only answer: people already have phones and headphones. Forcing everyone to hear one soundtrack ignores personal choice.

Is this good for a party or classroom warm-up?

Yes, it is a perfect warm-up. It is quick to grasp, low stakes, and full of chances for jokes. It works well for nervous beginners and on streams, where viewers may hum their favourite lift tunes.

More motions

All motions