Contradicto Play Contradicto

Debate motion Absurd

Every office should have a resident goose

Picture a goose waddling between desks, honking at deadlines, and guarding the kitchen. This motion is absurd, but it makes a real point about workplace morale, animals at work, and office culture. Winning means making the jury laugh while building a clear case about what a goose would really add to, or cost, an office.

FOR Argue that the motion is right.

AGAINST Argue that the motion is wrong.

Arguments FOR

Arguments AGAINST

Sample openers

FOR

Our office has motivational posters. Imagine what it could achieve with a motivational goose.

AGAINST

I have met geese. They do not want to work here, and frankly, you do not want them to either.

How a match plays

Questions

How do I win an absurd motion like this?

Treat it seriously enough to reason it through. Think about morale, safety, animal welfare, and cost. Jurors love humour, but they reward jokes that make a point. A funny image of a goose guarding the fridge works if it shows a real benefit or risk.

What is the strongest rebuttal to the morale argument?

Point out that real morale comes from fair treatment and good work, not a novelty animal. A goose might be fun for a week, but it does not fix long hours or bad managers. It could even distract from real problems.

Is it good for a party or stream?

It is excellent for parties, streams, and office socials. It needs no research and brings out silly stories and creative ideas. It also works as a classroom warm-up to show how to argue playfully but logically.

More motions

All motions