Contradicto Play Contradicto

Debate motion Absurd

Ghosts should pay rent

If a ghost haunts your home, uses your space, and keeps you up at night, should it pay rent like any other tenant? This motion is wonderfully silly, but it raises real ideas about fairness, property, and what we owe the people, or spirits, we live with. Winning means mixing playful logic with a clear sense of justice.

FOR Argue that the motion is right.

AGAINST Argue that the motion is wrong.

Arguments FOR

Arguments AGAINST

Sample openers

FOR

If you rattle my pipes, slam my doors, and sit in my armchair at three in the morning, you are a tenant. Pay up.

AGAINST

This ghost lived here before you were born. If anyone owes rent, it might be you.

How a match plays

Questions

How do I argue an absurd motion convincingly?

Take the premise seriously and follow its logic. If ghosts are tenants, what rights and duties come with that? Jurors reward humour that builds a real point about fairness, property, or rules, and punish arguments that are only jokes.

What is the strongest rebuttal to the fairness argument?

Point out that ghosts cannot earn money, so rent is impossible to pay. Then flip it: if ghosts pay rent, they become legal tenants with rights, which might make them harder to remove. Your opponent's plan backfires.

Is this good for a party or Halloween stream?

It is perfect for parties, Halloween streams, and family game nights. Everyone can join in without research. It also works in classes as a playful way to discuss fairness, contracts, and responsibility.

More motions

All motions