Contradicto Play Contradicto

Debate motion Daily Debate

Ketchup is a smoothie

Ketchup is made from tomatoes, which are fruit, blended into a thick, pourable sauce. So is it a smoothie? This motion is gloriously ridiculous, but winning means building a real definition of smoothie and defending it against every awkward example. The debate turns on whether ingredients and texture are enough, or whether purpose and use decide what a food is.

FOR Argue that the motion is right.

AGAINST Argue that the motion is wrong.

Arguments FOR

Arguments AGAINST

Sample openers

FOR

Blended fruit, smooth texture, comes in a bottle. Ketchup is not a sauce; it is a smoothie with excellent marketing.

AGAINST

If ketchup is a smoothie, I look forward to my opponent ordering a large one with a straw.

How a match plays

Questions

How do I win such a silly motion?

Treat it like a serious definition debate. Define a smoothie, then defend your definition with clever examples. Jurors reward humour and logic together, so a funny image, like a ketchup milkshake, works best when it proves your point.

What is the best rebuttal to the tomatoes are fruit argument?

Agree tomatoes are fruit, then argue that ingredients do not define a dish. Wine comes from grapes, and nobody calls it fruit juice. Jam is fruit, and nobody calls it a smoothie. Purpose and preparation matter.

Who is this motion for?

It is ideal for parties, streams, and classroom warm-ups. It needs no research and quickly gets everyone laughing. It also teaches a useful skill: how definitions decide arguments, even about breakfast and burgers.

More motions

All motions