Contradicto Play Contradicto

Debate motion Daily Debate

Mars is worth colonizing

Humans have dreamed of living on Mars for generations. This motion asks whether building a permanent settlement there is worth the enormous effort, risk, and cost. The debate turns on whether Mars offers humanity a backup plan and a great adventure, or whether the same resources would do far more good fixing problems here on Earth.

FOR Argue that the motion is right.

AGAINST Argue that the motion is wrong.

Arguments FOR

Arguments AGAINST

Sample openers

FOR

Every great leap in human history started with someone saying it was too far, too hard, and too expensive.

AGAINST

Before we build a second home on a frozen desert, perhaps we should take better care of the one we already have.

How a match plays

Questions

What is the strongest rebuttal to the backup planet argument?

Argue that even a badly damaged Earth would still have air, water, and gravity, which Mars lacks. Fixing problems here will always be easier than building a home there. The backup plan would be harder to survive in than the disaster it escapes.

Should I use space facts and costs?

Only facts you are sure of, and avoid specific cost figures unless you can name the source. Jurors punish unsourced numbers. Basic, well-known points, like Mars having thin air and cold temperatures, are safer and still persuasive.

Is this good for a science class?

Yes, it is excellent for science, geography, and ethics lessons. Students love space topics. It also works on streams, where viewers enjoy arguing about rockets, aliens, and the future of humanity.

More motions

All motions