Contradicto Play Contradicto

Debate motion Absurd

Pigeons should be allowed to vote

This motion asks whether city pigeons should get a say in elections. It is gloriously absurd, but arguing it well means thinking seriously about who gets a voice in democracy and why. The fun is mixing ridiculous images of pigeons at polling stations with real points about representation, the environment, and what makes someone fit to vote.

FOR Argue that the motion is right.

AGAINST Argue that the motion is wrong.

Arguments FOR

Arguments AGAINST

Sample openers

FOR

Pigeons live in our streets, suffer our decisions, and pay with their crumbs. No taxation without representation.

AGAINST

The first candidate to scatter breadcrumbs at the polling station would win by a landslide, and that is not democracy.

How a match plays

Questions

How do I argue an absurd politics motion without getting political?

Focus on general ideas, like who is affected by decisions and what voting requires, rather than real parties or politicians. Jurors reward humour that makes a real point, so let the pigeons carry a serious question about representation.

What is the strongest rebuttal to the affected parties argument?

Agree that pigeons are affected, then argue that being affected is not enough to vote. Children and many animals are affected by decisions too, but others protect their interests. Laws can protect pigeons without giving them ballots they cannot understand.

Who is this motion for?

It is perfect for parties, streams, and classroom warm-ups about democracy. It needs no research and lets everyone be creative. On Contradicto it is a favourite for players who want laughs with a surprisingly serious edge.

More motions

All motions