Contradicto Play Contradicto

Debate motion Absurd

The moon should be cut in half to make two moons

One moon is lovely, but imagine two. This motion proposes slicing the moon in half to give Earth a pair. It is gloriously absurd, but arguing it well means thinking about tides, night skies, poetry, and the risks of meddling with nature. The fun is making ridiculous ideas sound almost reasonable, or explaining with flair why they are a disaster.

FOR Argue that the motion is right.

AGAINST Argue that the motion is wrong.

Arguments FOR

Arguments AGAINST

Sample openers

FOR

One moon has inspired every poet in history. Imagine what two could do.

AGAINST

The moon has looked after our tides for longer than humans have existed. Let us not take a knife to it.

How a match plays

Questions

How do I argue such an absurd motion?

Treat it like a serious proposal with real consequences. Use simple science you are sure of, like the moon's effect on tides, and mix it with humour. Jurors reward wit that supports logic, so make every joke carry an argument.

What is the strongest rebuttal to the beauty argument?

Point out that beauty is not worth risking the oceans, satellites, and safety of everyone on Earth. The moon is already beautiful. Two broken halves might look more like a disaster than a wonder.

Who is this motion for?

It is perfect for parties, streams, and creative classroom warm-ups. It needs no research and invites imaginative arguments. It also teaches students to think about consequences, a key debating skill.

More motions

All motions