Contradicto Play Contradicto

Debate motion Hot takes

Hot dogs are sandwiches

A sausage in a bun: is that a sandwich? This motion is a famous food definition argument that sounds silly but tests your ability to define terms and defend edge cases. The debate turns on what a sandwich really is: bread around a filling, two separate slices, or something people simply recognise when they see it.

FOR Argue that the motion is right.

AGAINST Argue that the motion is wrong.

Arguments FOR

Arguments AGAINST

Sample openers

FOR

Bread, filling, sauce, held in one hand. If that is not a sandwich, I do not know what my lunch has been all these years.

AGAINST

Nobody at a sports game has ever stood up and shouted, I would like a sausage sandwich, please.

How a match plays

Questions

How do I win a definition debate?

Set a clear definition early and keep returning to it. Then test your opponent's definition with funny examples, like tacos, wraps, or burgers. Jurors reward clear thinking and humour, especially when a joke exposes a weakness in the other side.

What is the best rebuttal to the sub roll argument?

Say that sub rolls are filled with many different sandwich fillings, while a hot dog bun is made for one specific food. The bun and the sausage form their own dish, just as a taco shell and filling form a taco.

Is it good for parties and streams?

It is a classic for parties and streams. Everyone has a strong opinion, and the arguments get funny quickly. It is also a great classroom warm-up for teaching how definitions shape any debate.

More motions

All motions